Managers aim their abuse at those who are least likely to defend
themselves. That is the finding of a disturbing new study by Pedro
Neves (
published in the Journal of Occupational and Organizational Psychology), which looked at 193 supervisor/employee pairings in a variety of different industries.
I found the results troubling, but sadly they resonated based on my
experience as an executive team advisor in dozens of organizations.
Here is a summary of Neves’ findings.
Employees with poor core-self evaluations (an aggregate measure
related to self-esteem and sense of control) and poor coworker support
were more likely to experience aggressive behavior from their supervisor
(belittling, blaming, etc.). That is, the weakest employees receive the
brunt of a bad manager’s abuse.
The propensity to target aggression at the people least likely to
retaliate was exacerbated when the supervisor was in a stressful or
threatening situation (in this case post-downsizing). Supervisors under
stress did not become universally more aggressive, just more aggressive
toward the weakest members of their teams.
Employees with low core self-evaluations did not respond to the abuse
directly. Instead, they decreased their effort on their job duties and
reduced their discretionary effort on other tasks that support the team
or the organization.
In these findings, I immediately recognized a pattern of team dysfunction that I described in my book
You First and that I wrote about in a
previous post
for HBR. This toxic dynamic is created and worsened by three distinct
roles: the wicked manager who is preying upon the weak, the wounded
victim who fails to defend him- or herself, and the witnesses who do
nothing to interrupt the unhealthy interaction. Anyone playing any of
these roles can change the team by changing their behavior.
If You Are the Manager
First, if you are a manager, hold up a mirror and ask yourself
whether you play into this destructive dynamic. If you are honest with
yourself, do you take out your frustrations on the person on your team
who is least likely to fight back? Is there someone on your team caught
in a vicious cycle where his victim mentality has become a
self-fulfilling prophecy?
Just making yourself aware of this will start to change it for the
better. Then, decide what to do. Is there is a constructive way to
address the things that are frustrating you so that you don’t pass your
emotion on to the team? Even being aware that your frustrations come
from outside your team will help. If you have angst that comes from
uncertainty about your own situation, don’t take it out on your
subordinates, try to address it directly by asking for clarity from your
manager. If you’re angry about a decision from above, find an
appropriate outlet to express your concerns so they don’t get projected
onto the team.
Next, make a decision about the weak team member. There is no point
having a helpless person on your team. If it’s not worth the investment
to turn his behavior around, find another home for him or exit him from
the organization. If the person has a unique skillset or important
relationships with customers, it might be worth the investment to help
them succeed. Invest in building the person’s confidence and increasing
his credibility with his teammates.
Your negative words and body language toward the weak team member
have demonstrated to his coworkers that they don’t need to respect or
support him. If you pay attention to your own behavior, you’ll probably
notice that you don’t make much eye contact with him and that your body
is usually aimed away. Start shifting those subtle cues while you also
focus on being inviting and open in how you interact with him.
If You Are the Victim
If you’re the victim of the abusive manager, stand up for yourself.
Your attempts to grin and bear it without pushing back are inviting more
aggression. First, you need to realize that your boss’ behavior is
likely being triggered by stress she is under (i.e., it’s about
something other than you). When you present an easy target, she gets a
chance to let off some steam at your expense.
Let your manager know that you will not be a punching bag anymore.
Say something strong and respectful such as “I think we can resolve this
without raising voices,” or “My report had each of the pieces that we
discussed when we met on Tuesday.” Where it makes sense, enlist the
support of your coworkers “Brad, could you weigh in on this, we talked
through this approach.”
Finally, don’t get even by reducing your efforts on the job. It may
feel unfair and you may feel disengaged, but the last thing you want to
do is give your manager a valid basis for her treatment of you. Every
time you feel the desire to switch off your computer a little early,
channel that into a productive conversation or an important project.
If You Are the Witness
If you observe this kind of destructive relationship between your
boss and one of your teammates, get off the sidelines and do something.
Watching silently as a coworker is abused is no better than standing
idle as a kid is bullied on a playground. Remember, the research showed
that the supervisor abuse was much more likely to be targeted at people
who didn’t have the support of their coworkers.
Reach out to your teammate and provide support, advice, and coaching.
If there are things you believe she can do to come across as more
confident, pass along your ideas. In meetings, if you see abusive
behavior, try to defuse it. For example, if someone continually
interrupts her, ask that people hear her out. You might try something
like: “I’d like to hear what Sally has to say.” If the boss criticizes
her, be vocal when you disagree. Lending some of your confidence and
credibility might be the boost she needs to reclaim some respect from
the team and the boss.
Any one person can disrupt an unhealthy dynamic by behaving in a new
way. It takes the willingness to see and acknowledge the bad behavior
and the courage to do something differently. It’s worth it.
Liane Davey is the vice president of team solutions at Knightsbridge Human Capital. Her new book is
You First: Inspire Your Team to Grow Up, Get Along, and Get Stuff Done. She is also a co-author of
Leadership Solutions: The Pathway to Bridge the Leadership Gap. Follow her on Twitter at @LianeDavey.